Skip to main content

My most important lesson from Professor Clayton Christensen


This post first appeared in Medium, January 25, 2020

To those that dangle between the corporate and the startup world, the works of Professor Christensen are a must read.

They are useful both for startup teams in a mission to disrupt incumbents and for Boards and Executive Teams of incumbents considering how to react to innovators. I have used his models with many of the companies I worked with. For example when showing how innovators can disrupt the billion dollar industry of freight forwarders and how big incumbent freight forwarders should plan their moves to „disrupt the disrupter“.

Add caption

But the biggest lesson of Professor Christensen to me was actually a very different one

In June 2010 he announced that he had been diagnosed with follicular lymphoma. In July 2010, he had an ischemic stroke. This is enough for any human being to consider getting his „affairs in order“ and leave the stage to dedicate his time to the ones he loves.

But on a sunny and cold October 2010 day in Cambridge we had the honor to have him standing in front of us, the Advanced Management Program class 179 of the Harvard Business School. He came out of medical leave to give his first lesson after the stroke. This class to the AMP had been in his schedule before the disease and he forced himself to get fit and hold it, a tradition I later learned exists among HBS Professors: you never miss a class.

He started the class gently by explaining what was going on in his head. How he sometimes would just not find the right word in his brain. He said it was as if there would just be an empty hole where the word should be. Here and there he made a small stop but he gave a brilliant class. Not only on innovation, but also on human grit and will.

I had dreamed of attending classes of some the masters of strategy and business I so much admired. After teaching hundreds of consultants at Roland Berger Strategy Consultants the Porter 5 Forces and working in strategy for a decade at Lufthansa, it was moving to find myself seating in the classes with such amazing professors as Professor Michael Porter.

But that class of Clayton was special. His ideas on renewal and innovation were inspiring. And it certainly helped putting me on the track I am today with Pinto Ventures AG: investing and working with teams of innovators such as Monese, Bondora, EstateGuru and OttoQuant across the world.

That day, Professor Clayton Christensen was not only giving us a lesson. It felt as if he was giving himself a lesson. A lesson about being able to continue his passion and mission of teaching.

Many times we are faced with the biggest adversities and it seems like all we believed in has fallen apart. It is unavoidable that we will all have to go through such situations in life. Some certainly more dramatic than others, but all painful. It is then that you need the grit to stand up, shake the dust off and continue. And that first step is the hardest!

My biggest lesson from Professor Christensen was that life is indeed not about how many times you fall down. It’s about how many times you get back. And what makes you stand up is what you stand for.

I followed him in the media and had some exchanges with him and his team over email. I always listened or red attentively his teachings, ideas and humanistic ways.

We are going to miss you Professor Christensen!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Building the Future

Marc Andreessen of a16z, the Silicon Valley VC has recently published a fantastic post entitled " It's time to build ". He looks at how society has failed to see the Covid-19 crisis coming and how we as society are dealing with it. He claims "part of the problem is clearly foresight, a failure of imagination. But the other part of the problem is what we didn’t *do* in advance. [...] Our nation and our civilisation were built on production, on building. [...] There is only one way to honour their [our forefathers] legacy and to create the future we want for our own children and grandchildren, and that’s to build". Marc calls society to focus on building and less on rent-seeking of the accomplishments of our forefathers. The future is not built by societal-osmosis. The future of our societies is the sum of present actions taken by individuals and their teams over time. The success in building the future is the sum of the actions of special individuals. Thos

VonZu Posting

Investing in VonZu Tech - a memo to myself Globalisation and Retail Have you ever noticed that in the list of the richest people in every country there is always at least one Retail family? This is true in the US (e.g Walton family), Germany (e.g. Albrecht family), in smaller countries like Portugal (Soares dos Santos family) and is the same even in China (Ma family, Colin Huang).  There is a reason for this: retail goods and food is one of the highest spend categories of households in any country. The last massive transformation that made the money of many of this families was an invention from the 1960s: the sea container.  The evolution of retail via mega chains and stores with their professional category managers and international sourcing teams was made possible by this pice of logistics infrastructure. And this was very much what led to the massive expansion of global trade from 1960 to 2019. My hands-on experience with global trade was first gained as CEO of Spiriant GmbH in Ge
2022 statistics of Pinto Ventures: we received 300 qualified leads;  spoke with 65 teams; took forward conversations with 15 of them; took a closer look and did DD in 5 (less than 2%); and did only one new investment (to be disclosed soon). Why did we do all this work?  Selecting startups to invest is just 1/5 of our time. The rest is spent supporting teams throughout the ups and downs of building new profitable growing tech businesses, which is a very different approach from other early stage investors. How do others work? A typical early stage fund needs to create results after 10+ years for their investors or LPs. Investments are done in the first 1 to 3 years across ca. 20 to 30 companies. Portfolio construction is about maximising the chances of having at least one winner in each fund. The rule of thumb is that the “winner” investment will need to yield at least 1.5 times the size of the fund. Assuming an investment in equity of 20% and dilution until exit to 10%, this implies tha